Background: The role of consolidative radiotherapy (RT) in early-stage classic Hodgkin lymphoma (cHL) remains debated, particularly in the era of PET-adapted therapy. We evaluated real-world treatment patterns, outcomes, and toxicity of combined modality therapy (CMT; chemotherapy and RT) v chemotherapy alone.
Methods: We identified 810 consecutive patients with stage I-II cHL treated at eight academic centers between 2012 and 2020. Treatment was analyzed by intention-to-treat. Propensity score matching (PSM) by age, stage, sex, and prognosis (favorable v unfavorable per NCCN) yielded 480 patients for comparison of CMT (N=240) vs chemotherapy alone (N=240). Progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method. Subgroups were assessed by disease bulk and interim PET (iPET2) Deauville score (DS).
Results: Median age of the entire cohort was 33 (range 18-84); 436 (54%) were female. By intention-to-treat, 300 (37%) received CMT and 510 (63%) chemotherapy alone, with 90% receiving A(B)VD-based regimens. At median follow-up of 5.4 years, 5-year PFS and OS for the full cohort were 82% and 98%, respectively. In the PSM cohort, 5-year OS did not differ between CMT and chemotherapy alone (99% v 97%; p=0.620), but trended towards improved PFS with CMT (87% v 81%; p=0.053; Fig 1A). CMT improved PFS in bulky disease (92% v 73%; Hazard Ratio [HR] 3.8, 95% CI 1.4-10.2; p=0.005) and iPET2 DS≥4 (75% v 52%; HR 3.0, 95% CI 1.1-7.8; p=0.020; Fig 1B-C). Patients receiving CMT were less likely to relapse at sites of prior disease (7% v 18%; p<0.001). iPET2 DS4-5 was associated with inferior 5-year PFS (46%) v DS1-2 (92%) and DS3 (79%; p<0.001). Among iPET-positive patients, those who received unplanned consolidative RT were less likely to require salvage therapy than those treated with chemotherapy escalation alone (29% v 45%; p=0.037). CMT was associated with higher rates of hyperlipidemia, hypothyroidism, and second malignancy, though 69% of second malignancies occurred outside the RT field. Pulmonary fibrosis was more common with 6 v ≤4 cycles of bleomycin (4% v 0.4%; p=0.008) and when it occurred resulted in worse 5-year OS (50% v 99%; p<0.001).
Conclusion: In this large cohort, CMT and chemotherapy alone yielded comparable OS, but CMT conferred a PFS advantage in bulky or iPET2-positive (DS≥4) disease. These findings support a risk-adapted approach in which consolidative RT is preferentially considered for high-risk subgroup.
Alexandra Dreyfuss, Nikita Dave, Alison Moskowitz, Joachim Yahalom, Maria Alfaro, Nicole Birrer, Boyu Hu, Rachel Koch, Zachary Frosch, Meryl Colton, Carrie Ho, Behzad Amoozgar, Tatyana Feldman, Abhiraj Saxena, Joanna Rhodes, Ashley Dunton, Nirav Shah, Amelia Mantione, Harper Hubbeling, Michael LaRiviere, John Plastaras, Beatrice Desai, Brandon Imber, Reid Muenzen, Stefan Barta, Jordan Carter, Elise Chong, Michael Cook, Daniel Landsburg, Sunita Nasta, Stephen Schuster, Colin Thomas, Emily Tomasulo, Jakub Svoboda